Mobile Phone Offence: Ban Avoided
Our Case Study
Nature of the Offence
Mr Fraser had 6 active penalty points on his driving licence from a previous motoring offence. Whilst driving back from work during a hot summers’ day, he was stopped by the police for allegedly using his mobile phone whilst driving.
At the point of being stopped by the police, he explained immediately that he had a cold can of coke in his hand and he had momentarily placed that against his face as he was feeling very hot. He immediately denied using his mobile phone.
He subsequently received correspondence in the post explaining that he would be prosecuted for this offence.
Where the Offence Occurred
The offence occurred near Milton Keynes and the trial was listed before Northampton Magistrates’ Court.
Using a Mobile Phone Whilst Driving
Under Section 41D(b) of the Road Traffic Act 1988 a person caught using their mobile phone whilst driving is guilty of an offence and will receive 6 penalty points. If Mr Fraser pleaded guilty to this offence or was found guilty of this offence after trial, the total number of penalty points on his licence would have reached 12 and he would have received a Penalty Points Disqualification (Totting-Up Ban) of at least 6 months.
As Mr Fraser was a very high net worth business owner, the chances of him being successful with an exceptional hardship application were very low, given that he could afford to employ a chauffeur to drive him if he received a driving ban.
As Mr Fraser denied using his mobile phone, our lawyers advised him to plead not guilty and progress the matter to a contested trial.
On the morning of the trial, our lawyer spoke with the prosecutor and raised certain issues in the account given by the police officer. The prosecutor considered the issues we had raised and offered an alternative charge, Section 41D(a) of the Road Traffic Act 1988, this is an offence which relates to not driving a motor vehicle in a position which does not give proper control or a full view of the road and traffic ahead. This is an offence which attracts 3 penalty points, as opposed to 6 penalty points.
Mr Fraser accepted that he should not have been placing a can of coke onto his face whilst driving, he accepted he was guilty of Section 41D(a) of the Road Traffic Act 1988.
As a result of our lawyers’ ability to identify weaknesses within the prosecution case, the prosecutor amended the charge from Section 41D(b) to Section 41D(a). Mr Fraser pleaded guilty to the new offence and received 3 penalty points, taking the total number of points on his licence to 9 and avoided a driving ban.
Names have been altered for client confidentiality reasons
Traffic Commissioners are responsible for licensing and regulating operators of heavy goods vehicles (“HGVs”), public service vehicles (“PSVs”) including coaches and local bus services. They can also take action against drivers including suspending or revoking...
Will I get banned from driving with 12 points on my licence? Penalty points can be imposed against driving licences for a variety of offences such as speeding, careless driving, or using a mobile telephone whilst driving. For drivers who are at risk of receiving...
Our Birmingham based Driving Offence Lawyers are frequently asked about ‘Legal Loopholes in Driving Offences’ by clients / potential clients and whether we have a Birmingham Loophole Lawyer within our team that can save them from receiving a Driving Ban. In this...
Request A Callback or Email from a Kang & Co Solicitor
Do you require a solicitor? Please don't hesitate to get in touch with us. Use our quick contact form below and a member of our experienced and professional team of solicitors will contact you as soon as possible to discuss your requirements and your options.