Special Reasons Argument: Penalty Points Avoided
Our Case Study
Nature of the Offence
Mrs Brant was a motorist with 9 active penalty points and she was facing prosecution for speeding at 50mph on a road restricted to a speed limit of 40mph.
She accepted that she was the driver, and openly accepted that she was guilty of this offence. This was an offence which attracts 3 penalty points, and this would result in Mrs Brant reaching 12 penalty points on her driving licence and receiving a totting-up driving ban of at least 6 months.
Mrs Brant explained to our lawyers that her son had been at home and had sustained a severe injury, she attempted to call the emergency services however, her mobile phone was experiencing technical difficulties and as a last resort she decided to drive her son to the hospital for urgent medical attention.
She explained that the offence occurred whilst she was driving her son to the hospital, and that was the reason she was speeding.
Where the Offence Occurred
Mrs Brant lived in a village on the outskirts of Kidderminster and the offence occurred within Kidderminster town centre, as such her case was listed before Kidderminster Magistrates’ Court.
Special Reasons Argument
A ‘Special Reason’ is a reason which is special to facts of the case and the offence, it is essentially an extenuating or mitigating reason directly connected to the offence, which does not amount to a defence and a reason which the Court should take into consideration when imposing a sentence.
If the Court accepts the special reasons argument, it provides the Court with discretion not to impose any penalty points for the offence.
At the Court Hearing, Mrs Brant pleaded guilty to speeding and our lawyers raised special reasons (the fact that Mrs Brant was taking her son to hospital) and supported this with appropriate submissions and evidence. The court carefully considered the circumstances of our application and accepted that special reasons were present.
The Court endorsed 0 penalty points (as opposed to 3) and Mrs Brant avoided a totting-up driving ban, which would have been a ban of at least 6 months.
Names have been altered for client confidentiality reasons
In this "Quick Guide" we will take you through the law, the sentencing and the defence for the offence of Causing Death by Dangerous Driving in England & Wales.The offence of Causing Death by Dangerous Driving is contained within Section 1, Road Traffic Act 1988....
In this "Quick Guide" we will take you through the law, the sentencing and the defence for the offence of Causing Death by Careless Driving in England & Wales.The offence of Causing Death by Careless Driving is contained within Section 2B, Road Traffic Act 1988....
In this "Quick Guide" we will take you through the law, the sentencing and the defence for the offence of Driving without Insurance in England & Wales.The offence of Driving Without Insurance (No Insurance) is contained within Section 143 of the Road Traffic Act...
Request A Callback or Email from a Kang & Co Solicitor
Do you require a solicitor? Please don't hesitate to get in touch with us. Use our quick contact form below and a member of our experienced and professional team of solicitors will contact you as soon as possible to discuss your requirements and your options.